
066 What is an IDIQ Contract?
Paul: Welcome to the contracting officer podcast. If you work anywhere in the government acquisition world, this podcast is for you. Our mission to make government contracting better one contract at a time. Whether you work for government or industry, we're here to help you understand how the other side thinks. Today's episode is brought to you by Uninet.
Use Uninet for all projects, people, and financials, or integrate seamlessly with other accounting and ERP systems. Uninet provides a single source of truth that removes the barriers to sharing real time information caused by using separate business systems.
Kevin: As your business grows, it's very easy to unwittingly create information silos that cost you time and money. Unanet helps connect that information.
Paul: Yeah. And if you have those silos, that means you can end up with different answers to the same question depending on who you ask and what system they're using. Unanet breaks down those barriers and provides a single source of truth. Visit unanet.com. That's unanet.com/podcast
Kevin: to learn more. Or you can
Paul: attend one of their upcoming lunch and learn events. February 23rd in Orlando, Florida, February 24th in Tampa, Florida, and February 25th in San Diego, California. Visit uninet.com/podcast to register. Today's episode explains a very common contract type. Let's get started.
Hey, Kevin. Today, we're going to talk about IDIQ contracts.
Kevin: We are. IDIQ, it's a specific type of contract that's often misunderstood or partially misunderstood, and it's enough that it can create problems.
Paul: IDIQ is indefinite delivery, indefinite quantity. And what that means is you don't know how many you're gonna need or when you're going to need them, but you know you're going to need some amount, some minimum and maximum amount.
Kevin: So far time, for those of you reading along, it's far 16504 is where this is all explained. Basically, think of this as you take your kids bowling, and they could put up those little bars that come up through the through the in the gutters, and that way the ball doesn't go into the gutters. Right? So the basic idea is think of that image that you don't know how many bowling balls are coming down the lane, you don't know how fast they'll be going, but you know that there's gonna be some bowling, and it's gonna stay between these bumpers. That's the flexibility that an IDIQ contract has.
There's a requirement, get the bowling ball down the down the lane, But how many times, how fast, that might be determined after contract awards. So it's it's a fuzzy way to do contracts for some people if you don't understand it.
Paul: I can live with that analogy. May not be completely right, but I think I can think through that.
Kevin: Most of mine are a little bit fuzzy.
Paul: So this type of contract is used, and this is a far thing. It actually says, when it is inadvisable to commit for more than a minimum quantity. And contracting officers should only use IDIQs when there's a recurring need. So if you know for sure that you need a 100 of something, and you know that you're going to need a 100 more later or 500 more later, but you're not sure you might need a total of a 1000 or a total of 2,000, this is a great time for IDIQ. You don't know.
It's indefinite quantity. You're not sure exactly how many you need. So you don't wanna commit for more than the 100 you need today, but you know you're gonna go back for more.
Kevin: And this is different from a normal contract where you I want you to give me a 100 units, you give me a 100 units, I pay you for a 100 units, contract is over. That's what a regular contract looks like. That's why this IDIQ is so different.
Paul: That's a great way to explain it. We're in FAR 16504 still. It says you have a minimum requirement and a stated maximum requirement, and that's set by the CO and likely by the user's customer. This is where so we have to use some some estimation, but it sets the quantity. Over some period of time, you're going to order a minimum and possibly a maximum.
When those are going to be delivered is sometime between the beginning and the end of that period of performance.
Kevin: And do you feel all the flexibility on the government side? Yeah. All these examples we're giving of how this thing it seems like it's wide open, and that's those bumpers. They can those bumpers may be 3 or 3 or 4 lanes wide. And that's why you have to be careful, is understanding how far apart are those bumpers.
Because if you don't realize what you signed up for, again, I've seen it go badly.
Paul: Now I'm understanding the full value of this analogy. Don't set the bumpers the whole width of the bowling alley. We'll talk about why you shouldn't do that later.
Kevin: So that's funny.
Paul: So there's 2 main types of IDIQ contracts. There's single award and multiple award. Single award is just like it sounds like. You win a contract from an agency, from an office, and you're the only person that they're going to place orders with when they have requirements for whatever that contract is to deliver. So not necessarily a sole source award, you may compete to get that, but once you get it, all future orders for whatever that thing is go to you.
The other kind is multiple award, and this is where the government selects more than one company to hold this this master IDIQ contract. And in the future, when they have a requirement, they release an RFP for a task order or a delivery order, and those who hold the IDIQs compete for that work.
Kevin: So the example of a single award, far even uses a reference to this, for advisory and assistance services. In other words, you have somebody who's kinda treating you're treating them like your consultant. Right? You you as a government person, you hire a a company to be your consultant. That would be something that, as an example, would be a single award, because you don't wanna have 3 or 4 different consultants who are all following different projects you have at different paces.
You just want one point of contact. Right? Compare that to something for a a a commoditized product or a software, software maintenance package or grounds maintenance, more than one company could do it. All kinds of things like that that it makes sense to have multiple.
Paul: So the contracting officer must determine whether multiple awards are appropriate as part of their acquisition plan. So you want to avoid having an awardee for the IDIQ who specializes just in one thing and then will win everything. So the rest are just just ride alongs that that never really have a chance to compete. Right? The RFP has to tell the contractors upfront the the procedures and the selection criteria that the government is going to use for future task orders so that all awardees have a fair opportunity to be considered for it.
One purpose of the multiple award thing that we're talking about here is you limit competition for future task orders. Right? You've got the whole field of every contractor in the world that could ever bid on this. You do an IDIQ competition, and you award a contract to more than 1, thus the multiple. In your world, ideally 3.
Right, Kevin?
Kevin: Exactly. That's the magic number.
Paul: So then if you have 3 contractors that have your IDIQ contract, when you release an RFP for a task order, you know you're gonna get a maximum of 3 proposals. You know exactly who they are. All the other contracty stuff is already negotiated. You're really just competing for the work, the scope of that particular task.
Kevin: And those 3 companies will get better and better at serving you because they're laser focused on competing with each other. They know who their competition is. And from the industry side, that's kind of a neat thing to have. As you know who you're competing with, it helps you refine your strategy and actually do a better job of, writing a more targeted proposal.
Paul: So let me tell you about multiple award gone rogue. This is this is a horror story that, unfortunately, it's not it's not just a single example. In in you and I's lives, we've seen it happen more than once recently that the government has conducted a competition to award multiple award IDIQ to limit that competition. Somewhere during the source election, things have gone awry and there's been a protest, and the remedy that the government has chosen is we'll just award an an IDIQ contract to everybody that bid. So instead of limiting their competition and getting it down to 3 or 5 or even 10, the government goes through a giant competition and ends up awarding 30 or 40 contracts, giving giving a contract to everybody that that said I'm interested.
So in the future, they're gonna compete for task orders amongst that entire field. Why did they do the multiple award in the first place? They could have just done individual source selections every time a new requirement came up. So instead of instead of getting it down to where now it's really easy for the government to compete amongst the 5 most qualified people, it's wide open all over again.
Kevin: Alright. So let let me let me put the, the contracting officer hat on this one. This story for the contracting officers who listen to the podcast, this is the story that you tell to the lawyers and everybody that says, oh, well, we can just let everybody in. Your answer to that and, again, we have a lot of people who listen who don't understand what actually happens. We're making government contracting better one contract at a time.
The consequence of that is that you say, well, why do we bother doing this this down select in the first place?
Paul: Just wasted tons of time and tons of money for zero benefit that it's only gonna be more complicated in the future.
Kevin: And and here's the other side. From the industry side, you could have as many as 20 proposals, 19 of which of those companies have no chance to win. And next time this big contract comes up, they're probably not gonna bid.
Paul: We're both pretty passionate about this one because it's happened more than once and it it's it's mind blowing that that that's the answer. Alright. Off off the soapbox. Back to topic. What factors should be considered when you're working on a multi award contract?
The acquisition phase of this. Right? So the scope and complexity of the requirement, if this is a long term, we have to develop something, that's probably not the right type of thing for a multi award contract. The most common use of them is for, what, delivery of commodities or some type of of commodity service, if that if that makes sense?
Kevin: Yeah. More often than not, we use it the term commodity is kind of thrown around, but something something that more than one company makes, something you're gonna be buying on a repeated basis. We use it for equipment. We use it for in the services lane, don't think in terms of commoditized service, just think in terms of services lots of people could provide. So, management services, acquisition support services, maintenance, all kinds of things that they they may not be a commodity.
It may not be something you're gonna find on Amazon, but it's something that more than one company can do.
Paul: Yeah. In my world, a lot of times it's used software development. You do the IDIQ competition to get it down to a handful of companies that have the resources to do the kind of development that you have. And as these small smaller you know, we're not talking many, many 1,000,000 of dollars, but as these smaller tasks come out, you can maintain vibrant competition amongst the most qualified people through the multi award.
Kevin: Yeah. The the big key thing you mentioned there was it allows the ability to maintain competition. The thing that pops in my head is how do you know you're getting the best service? Well, if you've got 3 or 4 companies giving you their best shot every time, you as an agency, you as a customer know, okay, I'm not just winging in here. I'm getting I'm I'm benefiting from the market without actually having to go to the entire market every time.
Paul: And one of the best ways to make sure that this competition is gonna exist, I've actually seen IDIQs where the government has said, as we go through, this is a 5 year period, every year, we're going to take a look and use an on ramp off ramp kind of strategy where if we're not getting enough competition, we, the government, reserve the right to add more companies. Even though we already held the IDIQ competition, we may add more companies and give them IDIQ contracts so that they can compete against you folks that already hold 1 who aren't competing well right now. And also, if you got the ID if you were awarded the IDIQ contract and you haven't actually bid or haven't submitted a credible bid yet, they will off ramp you and end your contract for convenience and make their job easier because now they know that you're not gonna submit any more proposals that waste their time. Or they don't even have to worry about you submitting a proposal anymore because you you didn't prove that that you were, what, worthy of the IDIQ? Is that the right word?
That's kinda mean.
Kevin: Well, you weren't you weren't using it. Right. You weren't, you know, you're it's it's kinda like having a a GSA schedule that you don't use. After a while, a GSA is like, dude, if you're not gonna get $25,000 worth of of revenue off of this, we're not gonna pay to maintain it for you. So that's Exactly.
Paul: So back to the FAR stuff, when not to use multiple awards. The FAR gives you a list of when the contracting officer must not use a multiple award approach. I love it. Not shall, but must not. So if there's only 1 contractor that's capable of doing this because it's unique or highly specialized, don't waste everybody else's time with a multiple award.
Number 2 on the list is actually the thinking part of that contracting officer job. I know you love that, Kevin. If the CEO, based on their knowledge of the market, can justify that a single award will give them more favorable terms and conditions, including that price, they should not use multiple awards. They're wasting their time, they're wasting industry's time.
Kevin: And the example here is if you the size of the contract, if you have a small business set aside and you know that the kind of companies that can do this, even though it's a small business set aside, it might be a large contract for small businesses. So it makes more sense to have what based on what you know about the companies in this market because you've done your market research, it makes more sense to just write a a document that says, we're just doing this as a single award, IDIQ, and move on. So use the thinking job. And, again, I put this out there because I don't know if all contracting officers know about this part of the FAR. It says, based on your knowledge of the market, you don't have to have a multiple award.
That's a big deal. So what's the third one?
Paul: So next it says, if the expected cost of administration of multiple contracts outweighs the expected benefits, you shouldn't use a multiple award. So if it's a low dollar value thing, it actually uses the threshold for simplified acquisition procedures as as a line. It's what makes sense for that acquisition that you're talking about. But if it's small dollars, the it does take more time and energy to compete amongst multiple contractors when you could just place an award to 1. Use that balancing act when you're making this decision, government.
And lastly, there's the catchall. Multiple words should not be used if they're not in the best interest of the government.
Kevin: So There's a wide open space. That's why
Paul: Yeah. But back to the thinking part of the job. Right. Here's a weird random FAR number. I know you love those too.
The FAR says that you can't award a task or a deliverer contract that exceeds a $112,000,000 to a single source without head of agency approval. And they have to just write this in writing, and and meet certain criteria. But, a 112,000,000.
Kevin: That's right. And it and it's it's really interesting how they picked some of these numbers, but the the basic strategy here is at the bottom of this one too, it says, unless it is necessary and then in the public interest. With again, I I never had the right of justification based on that, but if you do, it's gonna be based on a $112,000,000 contract because that's apparently some magic number.
Paul: 112. Let's talk about why this matters. Why is this so important? IDIQ contracts are easier in some ways, and they're actually harder in some ways. But it's important because there are a lot, and I mean a lot of IDIQ contracts, especially multiple award IDIQ contracts out there in the government contracting world.
Kevin: Yeah. I I would say if I had to pick a number, I'd say up to half of the dollars that I awarded were were under some type of IDIQ. Single award, multiple award, GSA, whatever. Yeah.
Paul: And there's some places that's probably all they do.
Kevin: Yeah. That's true.
Paul: Alright. Let's get specific. Government side, why should the government care about this? This gives government agencies, offices, whatever, maximum flexibility in placing their orders. It doesn't commit you to, I need exactly this many at exactly this time.
So it leaves it open. I know I'm gonna need a bunch of stuff. I don't know exactly how much or when. Boom. IDIQ.
Kevin: It also limits competition. And what we mean by that is after the award is done, you've you're down to 3 companies. So instead of having to put it out to the world, like we talked about a few minutes ago, you're down to just 3 companies, which speeds up the process. Right.
Paul: Unless you cave and just award it to everybody that bid and then you're
Kevin: Oh, let it go, man.
Paul: Okay. I'll let it go. IDIQs, when done correctly, they make it really easy on the government to buy what they need to buy. You just place an order against an existing contract. Okay.
Give me 50 of those. Done. No justifications, no competitions, it's already done. And even if it's a multi award, it's somewhat of a streamlined competition compared to a big source selection. Most of the documentation is already written.
All of the how we're going to get proposals, what the requirements are, all the section m, section le kind of stuff are already defined in the IDIQ. So you're really just saying, alright. Bid like we already told you about on this requirement.
Kevin: And so here's an example of why this is important on the government side. This is a a passionate one for me. So we had a company that won a contract for, we'll call them widgets, and they thought that the 1600 widgets that we bought over the that was the the ceiling. 1600 widgets is how many we're going to buy. It was a 5 year contract.
And and we in the 1st year, we bought 400 of these widgets. And they just did the math and said, okay. Well, divide by the rest, and they're gonna order about 300, a year for the rest of the contract. An IDIQ contract doesn't work that way. Right?
Now, you know that after listening to the last 15 minutes, but in in reality, a lot of companies don't understand how that impacts their cash flow. Here's the point on the the contracting officer side. I almost put these guys out of business because I did not explain to them. Oops. Because they they were gonna go out and buy a building.
They were gonna go out and, you know, and and because because they were thinking in terms of, oh, this 400 unit capacity, that's the standard. That was the initial surge. It's gonna taper off after that depending. And by the way, 4 years from now, who knows what we're gonna need? You know, maybe there's an ISIS issue, you know, this it's a lot of flexibility in these contracts.
So make sure that your company understands it, but you as a government, make sure they understand what does your flow look like. Because it's it's a contract admin exercise. You're you're making sure they understand what this contract's gonna look like for the next 4 years. Because when they call you out of the blue and go, oh, oh, crap. I just hired 2 people.
Now I gotta fire them because you didn't order this. You're just you're wasting time having that conversation. Oh, you have that conversation upfront and say, yeah. We did 400 this 1st year. We're probably not gonna order more than a 100 for the next, you know, I don't know, 4 years.
That now they know as opposed to them guessing and guessing wrong.
Paul: Yeah. This goes this goes back to one of our regular themes, Kevin. It's it's communication. Right? You can put together this great IDIQ contract that's gonna give you lots of flexibility and then mess it all up when the you you place an order for 500, the contractor's expecting future orders.
You don't you know that those 500 are actually gonna last you a couple years, but the contractor's expecting that they're gonna get another another order for 500 soon. By the time you place the order, they might not be there to deliver it. So this is just that the communication, and some some I've seen it done very, very well, where there's a forecast and it's updated regularly, and both sides know the expected flow and talk about changes to that flow. And I've seen it where IDIQs are awarded and then almost forgotten about until an order comes up, and then everybody's surprised.
Kevin: So why should the industry care? It's your favorite part.
Paul: Industry should care because it makes it really, really easy for the government to buy from you. If you have an IDIQ contract that single award, all they have to do is place an order. Saves everybody time and energy and money. That's that's what we're always talking about here. You want the government to have an easy easier time placing an order with you than with anybody else because that's the way that they'll go.
Kevin: It's a path of least resistance. And as a contracting officer, I love them because, number 1, I still have competition. Number 2, I can award quickly. I have I have year end money. I I have a lot of things I need to get for my customer.
Which ones are the easiest to award first? Well, the ones they already have a contract for. Right. I can get it's a little hanging fruit. Right?
And and the other side of this is that I know who the the companies who are going to bid are. So think of that from the industry side. You know who your competitors are. I mentioned it once before here. The idea of if it's a multiple award, you know who your competitors are.
Compare that to the commercial market where you you may think you know, but, I mean, it's written down in this case. Three companies got the award. You know exactly who they are. That's that's kind of a unique thing.
Paul: Yeah. From the industry side, I know there's often requirements looking for a home. The government will have a requirement. They don't have time, or don't think they have time, to do a giant competition to get this thing delivered. So they go looking for IDIQs that have the scope, the proper scope, to fit their requirement.
And they will give the money to the the office that owns that IDIQ and say, put out a task order or place an order for this on my behalf. So in industry side, if you have these IDIQs with proper targeting and proper communications with your customers, you can drive work to your existing IDIQs and bring work that might not have been contemplated originally for it, but fits. You can bring that work to you, and the government will love it because they don't have to go through all of the usual mess of acquisition in order to buy it. They can just place an order because you already have the contracts like you just said, Kevin.
Kevin: And so the here's the 2 other things to consider. Make sure that you don't overshoot what they're gonna spend on your contract, like the story I just told about them almost going out of business. But then also make sure that you don't undershoot. Had a contract for it was an IDIQ contract. There was a lull of about 6 months between orders, and my contract specialist calls up the the company and says, hey, by the way, we're gonna place this order.
And the the simplest description would be it's almost like they were asleep at the wheel. They're like, what? We have a contract with you guys? So, yeah. Like you said, they're they're sometimes sometimes they're forgotten.
Now, there's I remember the name of that company and, yikes, I'm amazed they got a contract. But still, the point is, you know, don't under assume that, like, well, they're never gonna call me. I got my first order and forget about it. Make sure you've this is this is part of the complex sale is you gotta keep that relationship alive, you know, there's you have some responsibility to engage, so communication goes both ways. But I've seen both extremes and you wanna land somewhere in the middle.
Paul: Alright. So one more reason why industry should care. Industry loves to trumpet wins. Right? So lots of times, companies win.
Yes. We won a $100,000,000 IDIQ contract. Well, that $100,000,000 is the ceiling. And if it's a multiple award, you may never see a single dollar of revenue from that contract. Right?
You still have to compete for the work on the multiple awards. And for single awards, you may get the minimum order, which is $1,000,000 and never get the under 99,000,000. But it's important for industry to understand that there is no promise. That's the indefinite part. There is no promise in that of the value, but it does look good in a press release.
Kevin: And in order to manage these properly, make sure you're creating a flexible supply chain. And what I mean by that is the whole story of don't go out and buy a building, that's a fixed cost. Right? Don't go out and hire a whole bunch of new employees, that's a fixed cost. The idea of what can you do to be able to to manage this on a flexible basis?
And just thinking about that, we have clients that just having this conversation about what pieces of this process can we design that are that are scalable up and down without a whole lot of hassle. If you're not having that conversation before you get the task order, that's kind of bad. If you're not having it after you get the task order, you're really gonna be in trouble because it's gonna blow up in your face.
Paul: That's a great place to wrap this up. Government side, remember, make sure the multi award situation makes sense. Make sure this IDIQ thing is the easiest way to do stuff. And resist the temptation to mash all your requirements together in one giant IDIQ, like, maybe for the entire command or something like that. It gets really complicated when you add too many unlike things to an IDIQ.
At that point, you might be better off competing them individually. Industry side, know the difference. Know that this is not a guaranteed contract. Only the minimum is guaranteed.
Kevin: So for example, if in your contract, the letter after the year is a c, that's a one and done contract. If it's a d, which stands for IDIQ, then this applies. I know that sounds like a really simple concept, and and, really, the big thing for me is this this flexible supply chain thing, is really understand that even if you were going after IDIQ contracts, you don't actually have one yet, that's a conversation that you should be having. And, you know, building up the relationships with your supply chain so they understand what this looks like.
Paul: Yeah. That's huge for me on the industry side. You have a contract there. The government will want to use an existing contract over having to start a new one. You can drive new work to your existing IDIQ contracts.
Kevin: Yeah. This is that 80 20 rule. Right? The 80% process, 20% relationship. Well, getting you the IDIQ contract was a whole lot of process.
Now that you got it and managing it correctly, there's some relationship.
Paul: That's where the relationship is. Alright. That's it for today's episode. If you like the CO podcast, please tell a friend. We're all over LinkedIn and Facebook and Twitter.
Kevin: And we have a contracting officer podcast page on all three of those social media. And we also have a survey we've been putting out. We'd love to hear from you. We'd love to hear what topics you'd like to hear. One of the best ways for us to create content that is helpful to you is for you to tell us what it is.
Yes. Create content like this.
Paul: Send me your topics. Send them to paul@contractingofficerpodcast.com.
Kevin: And in the meantime, have a great day.
Paul: Alright, Kevin. I'll talk to you later.
Kevin: Alright. See you, Paul.
Paul: That's it for another episode of the Contracting Officer Podcast. As always, if you have questions, comments, or complaints, send me an email at paul@contractingofficerpodcast.com. Thanks for listening. It says must, not shall, but wait. I'm not even sure if it says must.
Does it say must?
Kevin: No. It it it the answer is this is a good one. This is funny. It says must to the best extent practicable, which is kinda like saying should. But that's what it says.
Just just putting it out there. So it says so the the contracting officer must to the the best extent practicable in parenthesis. So it kinda, you know, deletes the must in in a way. Anyway, keep going.