Subscribe Member Home
Episode 584 0.5 CLP

584 – Qualification-based Selection and the Brooks Act (with Bill Scheier)

Members only

This episode is available with a Skyway membership.

See membership options Member login

For more than 50 years, the Brooks Act has shaped how the federal government acquires architect-engineer services, putting qualifications and expertise ahead of low price. While most government contracting discussions focus on competition and cost, the Brooks Act takes a different approach. It recognizes that when public safety, critical infrastructure, and long-term project success are at stake, selecting the most qualified professionals matters most.

In this episode, Kevin and Bill break down what the Brooks Act is, why Congress created it, and how it continues to influence federal acquisition today. We'll explore the origins of qualifications-based selection, discuss its lasting impact on contracting practices, and explain why this unique law remains one of the most important foundations of architect-engineer procurement. Whether you're a contracting officer, government employee, or contractor, this episode offers valuable insight into a law that continues to shape federal contracting decades after its passage.

-----

~Show Notes~
Reach out to Skyway Acquisition - Podcast@skywayacq.com
Episode Summary
This episode explains the Brooks Act, a landmark 1972 law that requires federal agencies to select architect-engineer (A&E) firms based on qualifications rather than price. The law established the foundation for Qualifications-Based Selection (QBS), ensuring that public safety, project quality, and long-term value take priority over low-cost proposals.

The hosts discuss the history of the Brooks Act, its lasting impact on federal procurement, and how it became the statutory basis for A&E contracting procedures. The episode also reviews when the Brooks Act applies, key exceptions, the relationship to FAR Part 36 and the FAR Overhaul, and why qualification-based selection continues to benefit both the government and contractors.

Key Takeaways
  • Brooks Act signed into law in 1972.
  • Requires selection of A&E firms based on qualifications, not price.
  • Established Qualifications-Based Selection (QBS).
  • Agencies publicly announce requirements and evaluate firms based on competence and experience.
  • At least three firms are ranked before price negotiations begin.
  • Negotiations start with the highest-ranked firm.
  • Applies primarily to professional A&E services related to construction and facilities projects.
  • Influenced later best-value and past-performance acquisition concepts.
  • Research indicates QBS projects experience fewer cost overruns, schedule delays, and change orders.
  • Protects public safety by ensuring qualified professionals design critical infrastructure.
  • Benefits contractors by emphasizing expertise, experience, and professional capability over low-price competition.
  • FAR Part 36 implements Brooks Act requirements and was significantly revised under the FAR Overhaul.
 
***When does it matter (time zones)
Acquisition Time zones
-Market Research Zone
-RFP Zone
-Selection Zone
 
 
Current FAR Reference List: (https://www.acquisition.gov/browse/index/far)
FAR 6.302
FAR Part 15
FAR Part 36
FAR Subpart 36.6
FAR 36.601-3(b)
FAR 36.601-4(a)(1)
FAR 36.601-4(a)(3)
FAR 36.601-4(a)(4)
 
Overhauled FAR References (FARO) List: (https://www.acquisition.gov/far-overhaul/far-part-deviation-guide)
FAR O 36.2
FAR O 36.102-2
FAR O 36.102-2(d)
FAR O 36.202-4
FAR O 36.101-2
FAR O 36.202-3
FAR O 36.102-2(a)
 
CO Podcast List: (https://contractingofficerpodcast.com/library/)
Episode 317 – Acquisition and Execution Time Zones
Episode 322 – What is a Down Select?


References and resources for the show notes
  • “Celebrating the 50th Anniversary of the Brooks Act” — John Palatiello, published by CMAA. This appears to be the article the speakers refer to when discussing the Act’s connection to public safety. Read the article. 
  • “Swearing in of Lyndon B. Johnson as President” — LBJ Presidential Library. The photo caption identifies Jack Brooks behind Jacqueline Kennedy. View the photo. 
  • 40 U.S.C. § 1103 — Brooks Act selection procedures. View the statute.
  • “Hartford Civic Center Arena Roof Collapse” — UNC Charlotte building failure case study. Read the case study. 
  • “An Analysis of QBS in the Procurement of Engineering Services” — ACEC Research Institute’s 2022 report, titled Savings, Innovation & Efficiency. Read the report. The report identifies its earlier study as 2007, while the slide deck says 2009; please verify that year before publishing. 
  • “ACEC Comments on FAR Companion Version 1.0 (Final)” — ACEC’s comments on the FAR overhaul. Open the PDF.
  • “FAR Overhaul – Part 36” — Acquisition.gov. View the Part 36 guide. 
  • “QBS” — ACEC Missouri. View the QBS page.