
Episode 585 0.5 CLP
585 – Peer Reviews
Every contracting professional wants to make sound decisions, avoid costly mistakes, and deliver successful outcomes. One tool that can help achieve all three is the peer review process. While peer reviews are often associated with large, complex acquisitions, the principles behind them apply to contract actions of all sizes. A well-executed peer review brings fresh eyes, experienced judgment, and valuable feedback before key decisions are finalized.
In this episode, Kevin and Paul explore why peer reviews matter, when they add the most value, and how they can strengthen acquisition outcomes. We discuss the difference between reviews that genuinely improve decision-making and those that simply add another layer of process. Along the way, we'll share practical examples, lessons learned, and strategies that contracting professionals can use to improve quality, reduce risk, and make better business decisions. Whether you're in government acquisition or supporting federal contracts as a contractor, you'll find ideas you can apply right away.
-----
~Show Notes~
Reach out to Skyway Acquisition - Podcast@skywayacq.com
Peer reviews are independent assessments performed by experienced professionals to improve the quality, consistency, and effectiveness of contracting decisions. The episode compares peer reviews to home inspections: it is far less expensive to identify problems before releasing an RFP or awarding a contract than after decisions have been made. The hosts emphasize that peer reviews should be viewed as valuable quality checks, not simply administrative hurdles.
The discussion focuses on DFARS 201.170 peer reviews, which are formally required for certain DoD acquisitions valued at $1 billion or more. However, the concepts are useful for acquisitions of any size. The objectives include promoting consistent application of acquisition policies, improving contracting processes, and sharing lessons learned across organizations.
A key theme is balancing oversight with efficiency. Poorly executed peer reviews can become bureaucratic "time vampires," while effective reviews provide meaningful feedback that improves acquisition strategies, risk management, and business decisions. The hosts recommend conducting reviews as early as possible, especially before RFP release, when feedback can still influence outcomes.
The episode also explains the formal peer review phases for competitive and noncompetitve acquisitions, discusses useful guidance from the DFARS PGI, and highlights that peer review recommendations are advisory rather than mandatory. Ultimately, contracting professionals should focus on improving outcomes, using sound judgment, and involving contractors early when appropriate.
Key Takeaways:
• Peer reviews are independent quality checks intended to improve contracting decisions.
• Problems found before RFP release are cheaper and easier to fix.
• DoD requires formal peer reviews for certain acquisitions valued at $1B+.
• Peer review recommendations are advisory and do not replace contracting officer judgment.
• The best value comes from conducting reviews early in the acquisition process.
• Contractors should expect longer acquisition timelines when peer reviews are required.
• Contractors involvement before RFP release can improve acquisition outcomes.
• Oversight requirements tend to increase and decrease over time; peer reviews may become more common in the future.
***When does it matter (time zones)
Acquisition Time zones
-Market Research Zone (1)
-RFP Zone (2)
-Selection Zone (3)
Competitive
(1) Issuance of the solicitation.
(2) Request for final proposal revisions (if applicable).
(3) Contract award.
Execution Time zones
-Performance (1) and (2)
Non-competitive, including mods to existing contracts
(1) Negotiation.
(2) Contract award (or modification)
Current FAR Reference List: (https://www.acquisition.gov/browse/index/far)
FAR 1.108(c) – Dollar Thresholds
FAR 6.103
FAR 6.103-5
FAR 6.103-7
FAR 6.104 – Justification and Approval
FAR 16.401(e)(1) – Award Fee Determinations
DFARS 201.170 – Peer Reviews
PGI 201.170 – Peer Reviews
PGI 201.170-1 – Objectives of Peer Reviews
PGI 201.170-3 – Administration of Peer Reviews
PGI 201.170(g) – Competitive Acquisition Preaward Peer Review
PGI 201.170(g)(2) – Competitive Acquisition Preaward Example
PGI 201.170(h) – Noncompetitive Acquisition Preaward Peer Review
Law:
10 U.S.C. § 4022 – Other Transaction Authority (OTA)
10 U.S.C. § 3458 – Commercial Solutions Openings (CSO)
CO Podcast List: (https://contractingofficerpodcast.com/library/)
Episode 87 – What is a Source Selection Evaluation Board (SSEB) Report?
Episode 87 – What is a Source Selection Evaluation Board (SSEB) Report?
Episode 317 – Acquisition and Execution Time Zones
Episode 396 – What is a Red Team Review?
Links:
PGI 201.170-3 – Administration of Peer Reviews
PGI 201.170 – Peer Reviews
Sole Source Peer Review Preparation and Checklist
FAR 16.401 – Incentive Contracts
USAspending.gov