In my last blog, I talked about the exceptions to competition listed in FAR Part 6.302. I know many contractors do not understand why the government decides not to compete in many acquisitions. I will tell you that there are significant reviews done before the decision is made not to compete. COs are required to sign off on every non-competed decision. While the CO may make those decisions below the Simplified Acquisition Thresh hold (SAT) without review, any company that sees the RFQ can challenge that decision to the CO or Government Accountability Office (GAO). Each agency requires that a formal Justification and Approval (J&A) be sent through a review chain above certain dollar levels. My last job was at the Naval Air Systems Command, NAVAIR, where I was the CO for a Program Management Office. While my warrant authority was unlimited, my J&A signatory authority was $500,000, which still required the Office of Counsel's concurrence. The yearly production contracts for a system the Navy had been buying for 40 years still required a J&A, and if over $78M required, the Department of the Navy's Assistant Secretary of the Navy (Research, Development, and Acquisition) approval. Of course, at least three Senior Executive Service (SES) employees reviewed that document before making it to the Secretary's desk.
J&As fall into three categories: Sole source award of a single contract to one contractor, Limited competition for the award of a single contract based upon restricted competition, and a class J&A for the award of multiple contracts for a particular program using one J&A. The class J&A permits an agency to award multiple contracts without getting a J&A approved for each contract. It is used on many larger programs to allow for multiple acquisitions supporting a program, sometimes linked to a Basic Ordering Agreement.
There are seven exceptions to competition, and the most widely used is the first:
6.302-1 Only one responsible source and no other supplies or services will satisfy agency requirements.
The argument here is that only one company can meet the requirements and that competition would result in only one offer. Since this such a complex issue, I am going to address only hardware acquisitions in this blog. Determinations to not compete for services take a different approach, and I will address them in my next blog.
To most American taxpayers, the argument that you can only go to one place to buy something does not make sense. The choices the American consumer has to buy just about anything are many. If in the case of cars, if you buy a Ford, you can get it fixed at the local mechanic or a dealership based on who offered the best price. Sometimes that means getting alternative parts not manufactured or supplied by Ford. For the most part, there is a choice for the American consumer.
For DoD, it gets a bit more complex. What most Americans primarily buy is consumer goods. They are not buying a fighter jet or tank (okay I need a tank to drive on the beltway around DC but the Maryland State Police may disapprove of that). DoD invests billions every year in developing new military systems. The acquisition process to select a new system is usually competitive. DoD spends years getting these new systems through the acquisition process, development, and production started. In most cases, the services do not want commercial grade equipment, preferring more unique designs because of the battlefield use. When laptops came out, the laptops could not deal with being bounced around in a military vehicle. The result was the "ruggedized" laptop. At first, only one or two laptop manufacturers could meet the requirement, so they became the only source. Given the need for uniformity across the service, those manufacturers were the only acceptable sources for many years. Now, as the need for other non-federal users emerged for these types of laptops, it is less likely that the initial acquisition by an agency would be sole source.
A good example would be a scenario where the Marines decide they need to develop a new battlefield radio system. They will establish requirements and get funding put in a fiscal year budget, and then they will go out with an RFP for this new system. After months of evaluation and testing, they down select the winner. Now the radio goes into production. If the Marines decide to procure more with another production contract, it will require a J&A to go back to the manufacturer. The Marines will want every user to use the same radio. The radios are fielded with active units, and over time, they may require maintenance. When the radios need spare parts for repair, unless the Marines asked for a whole lot more procurement money, they didn't buy a technical data package sufficient to compete for spare parts that the OEM has designated as proprietary. Lacking the data to compete for spares, the Marines now will write a J&A to go sole source to get the spare parts. In some cases, that may be a second or third tier supplier that the OEM has agreed to sell directly to the Marines, but it is still a sole source.
Seeking approval to go to only one source, every agency must answer why no other supplier can meet the requirement. Also, the agency must address what steps could be taken to foster competition in the future. The agency may consider different sub-components suppliers, but it must be determined that an alternative part has the same fit, form, and function to consider the alternative. An agency may evaluate a part for possible future acquisitions. Still, it may not delay the current acquisition due to the time necessary to evaluate a new supplier's data package. The services are wary of using parts that may not function and could cause loss of equipment or life.
Do Civilian Agencies have the same situations? I would say yes. Many of these agencies acquire equipment for use by their employees of all types. The FBI would want all of its agents to carry the same sidearm, or the FDA may need a unique piece of test equipment only made by one company. There are numerous examples of why all the government agencies will write J&As using only one responsible source.
Next time I will talk about the decision not to compete for services that entail a very different approach.


