I was a brand new Contracting Officer (CO) when FAR Part 12, Acquisition of Commercial Items, was added. I was encouraged to purchase as many items/services as possible using “commercial” methods. There was minimal documentation required, and it was fast and simple! I even purchased an Air Force aircraft as a commercial item!
Eventually every CO began to take a harder look at the items/services the government was purchasing using commercial procedures. One I remember was a traffic collision and avoidance system (TCAS) for a trainer aircraft. Every aircraft (government and commercial) have TCAS boxes. One of the uses is to warn pilots when they are too close to the ground. Normal TCAS settings have a pretty low proximity warning because experienced pilots can pull up and recover quickly. However, for the trainer aircraft, the government wanted the warning to occur at a much higher altitude to guarantee the trainee pilot could either compensate or eject. To change this warning required re-writing the code in the chip in the TCAS box. So was that truly commercial if it was being “modified” to meet such a specific government purpose? We ended up buying it as a commercial item, based on the minimal cost to change the code.
Over time since FAR Part 12 became effective, there have been considerable interpretations, clarifications and policy letters issued that require additional documentation for the purchase of commercial acquisitions.
FAR 2.101 defines a commercial item as “Any item, other than real property, that is of a type customarily used by the general public or by non-governmental entities for purposes other than governmental purposes . . .” “General public” does not include Federal, state, local, or foreign government (DFARS 202.101, Pub. L. 110-181).
Today COs must make a well-documented determination on commerciality. Don’t depend on previous commercial item determinations. Take a hard look on a case-by-case basis to ensure what you are buying is truly commercial. Fully document market research that leads to a commercial item determination.
Most “defense” related items we procure are not commercial off the shelf (not sold in substantial quantities in the same form sold in the commercial marketplace).
If a contractor claims commerciality, they have to prove it and the prime contractor “shall” determine whether subcontracts meet the commercial item definition.
Remember, a commercial designation does not relieve the CO from determining price reasonableness nor does it relieve the offeror from providing data in support of that determination. The contractor is required to provide necessary data to assist CO in determining commerciality.
Bottom line is that both the CO and the contractor need to be confident that the item/service is commercial and that the pricing analysis and negotiations are conducted as such. Classifying an item/service incorrectly can affect the cost, warranty, and terms and conditions of the contract. The goal is to ensure meeting the requirement at a fair and reasonable price.


